Truths and Consequences: Documentary 'One of Us'

"Are some of us just born with an unshakable need to question the status quo, despite the consequences?"
Publish date:
Updated on

One of Us

explores the world of Hasidic Judaism, as filmmakers Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady follow the lives of brave individuals who make the decision to leave the insular ultra-orthodox community.

"Ewing and Grady had long felt compelled by the Hasidic communities in and around New York City,"

writes Kate Erbland

, "though they suspected that they wouldn’t be able to gain access, just by virtue of the very element that lured them: all that secrecy."

"You're just curious and you want to know," Ewing tells Erbland. "But we never thought to make a film about the community, because we're two secular women and they hate cameras. We were never like, 'Let's try that!' because we don't like to set ourselves up for failure. I mean, there's a reason why it hasn’t been done.” To read the full interview,

click here


"Ewing and Grady followed their subjects for about three years," explains

Loren King

, "gaining the trust that was necessary for such intimate and ultimately powerful access to their struggles. They found some of their subjects through the underground organization Footsteps [there's one in New York and one in Israel] that helps Hasidic Jews who want to leave the community. After winning its trust, the filmmakers were granted access to Footsteps meetings and members who gave their consent." To read the full article,

click here


"Their subjects are often partly obscured by shadows or visible only in the blurry reflection of a subway window, a fitting approach for a film about a group of people hiding in plain sight — conspicuous and yet somewhat ethereal," says

Lara Zurum

. To read the full article,

click here


"As filmmakers, we had to come up with a visual motif, and as the film is very voyeuristic, it was a style we adopted from the very beginning," Ewing tells

Erik Luers

. "This is a community that doesn't want to be photographed and doesn’t want to be in the media. They despise cameras and we weren't welcome there, to waltz in and film everything around us. And so we adopted a voyeuristic style with 'dirty foregrounds.'" To read the full article,

click here

One of Us

: How Netflix Documentarians Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady Penetrated Hasidic Brooklyn

Leaving the Hasidic Faith: Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady on One of Us

Interview: Heidi Ewing & Rachel Grady on What They Got Out of One of Us

Hasidic Jews Struggle to Break from the Sect in Netflix's One of Us

"We have always been drawn to stories that put the nature/nurture debate into stark relief," the co-directors explain. "Are some of us just born with an unshakable need to question the status quo, despite the consequences? The three main subjects of

One of Us

are jumping head first into the unknown.

"Their rocky journey from insular Hasidic Brooklyn out into the secular world – with its emphasis on radical individualism – is fraught with both doubt and exhilaration.

"These three brave people are bucking the exacting rules of their ultra-orthodox community to experience the world for the first time as true individuals. Their journey is a profoundly human one that took us by surprise."

Loki Films: One of Us

Jesus Camp

Directors Are Back With Searing New Documentary

One of Us

Image placeholder title