Camera Tests: Is There Really a Point Anymore? - Creative Planet Network

Camera Tests: Is There Really a Point Anymore?

Author:
Publish date:

David Shapton asks in RedShark: "How do we deal with the fact that you can make convincing-looking films with a smartphone?" In the piece, he suggests we might want to employ a kind of "Turing Test" when asking viewers of some kind of video project whether they'd just watched something made with very expensive camera gear or with a cheap piece of consumer equipment. With Alan Turing's test to determine if a machine had "intelligence", it was a question of whether a human interlocutor could tell if they were conversing with a person or a machine. If they didn't know, the machine could be said to be "intelligent."

In Shapton's camera test, "You'd show a film to a viewer and ask them whether it was shot on expensive equipment or, let's say, an iPhone. But you'd only ask them this after they've seen the film. The reason is that if you "prime" viewers to look for defects, then they're not watching the film as a neutral viewer. You see, as long as I wasn't told in advance that this film was shot on an iPhone, I don't think it would have ever occurred to me that it was made with anything other than a professional camera."

It's actually quite a significant question. If the answer is that test viewers can't tell the difference, that could shake up the entire industry (faster than it's already being shaken up).

Related

SquareBox_Worker-8

Square Box Systems at the 2018 NAB Show New York

In Booth N557 at the 2018 NAB Show New York, Square Box Systems will demonstrate why its flagship CatDV remains on the cutting edge of media asset management (MAM). CatDV brings new levels of collaboration and empowerment to small-, medium-, and large-scale enterprises around the world, enabling them to manage, repurpose, and monetize millions of assets with ease and efficiency.

Vinten-FH-145-fluid-head

The Vitec Group Brands and Products on Display at CAPER 2018

In partnership with Sistemas de Video Comunicación, we are pleased to feature a variety of products from across many of our brands that are designed for the professional audiovisual and broadcast industries. The Gemini soft panel, Astra and Sola LEDs, Vantage robotic head, and our all-new flowtech100 tripod will on be on display throughout CAPER 2018. Television producers, DPs, camera operators, lighting professionals, and audiovisual teams can incorporate any of our gear into their existing production workflows to help them capture beautiful images and produce exceptional content.